SMS 2FA is better than nothing, but it's also the weakest link in your account security. App-based TOTP codes are free, phishing-resistant, and far harder to intercept. We tested the top options — open-source, private, and hardware-backed — to find the best 2FA app for your threat model. Our picks: 2FAS for iOS users, Proton Authenticator for privacy purists, Bitwarden Authenticator for all-in-one convenience, and YubiKey for maximum hardware security.
If you're still using SMS codes to protect your accounts, it's time to upgrade. SMS two-factor authentication is vulnerable to SIM-swapping attacks, SS7 protocol exploits, and plain old carrier incompetence.1 A dedicated authenticator app generates time-based one-time passwords (TOTP) locally on your device — no phone number required, no carrier involved.
The best 2FA apps are open-source, encrypt your backups, and give you full control over your secrets. Here's what we recommend.
We focused on four criteria:
We consulted Wirecutter's testing and State of Surveillance's privacy-focused analysis to narrow the field.1
Go to 2FAS
2FAS is our top pick for iPhone users. It's fully open-source, has a clean interface, and offers a handy browser extension that auto-fills TOTP codes on your Mac.2 Backups are encrypted and stored in iCloud, so switching phones doesn't lock you out. The Android version is solid too, but the iOS experience is where it really shines.
| Dimension | Details |
|---|---|
| Open-source | Yes |
| Cloud sync | E2EE via iCloud |
| Platform | iOS, Android, Browser |
Go to Proton Authenticator
From the team behind Proton Mail and Proton VPN, this authenticator is built around a simple premise: your 2FA secrets should be encrypted end-to-end before they ever touch a server.2 It's open-source, audited, and integrates with the broader Proton ecosystem. If you already use Proton services, this is the natural choice. The E2EE sync means you can access your codes on multiple devices without trusting Proton's infrastructure.
| Dimension | Details |
|---|---|
| Open-source | Yes |
| Cloud sync | E2EE via Proton |
| Platform | iOS, Android |
Go to Bitwarden
If you're already using Bitwarden as your password manager, adding the built-in authenticator is a no-brainer. Your passwords and 2FA codes live in one place, synced with E2EE across every device you own.1 The trade-off: storing everything in one vault means a single master password compromise unlocks both. For most people, the convenience outweighs the risk — just make sure your master password is strong and unique.
| Dimension | Details |
|---|---|
| Open-source | Yes |
| Cloud sync | E2EE via Bitwarden |
| Platform | All (app, browser, desktop) |
Go to YubiKey
A YubiKey is a hardware security key that doesn't store secrets in software at all. It uses FIDO2/WebAuthn for phishing-resistant authentication — even if someone tricks you into visiting a fake login page, the key won't sign the request.1 It's overkill for most people, but if you're a journalist, activist, or just paranoid (in a good way), this is the gold standard. The downside: you need a physical backup key, and not every service supports hardware keys yet.
| Dimension | Details |
|---|---|
| Open-source | Firmware (partially) |
| Cloud sync | None (hardware-only) |
| Platform | USB, NFC, Lightning |
Google Authenticator and Microsoft Authenticator are widely used, but both have privacy concerns. Google Authenticator only recently added cloud backup — and it's not end-to-end encrypted, meaning Google can read your secrets.1 Microsoft Authenticator collects telemetry by default.2 Neither is fully open-source. There are better options.
Whatever you pick, just move off SMS. It takes five minutes and it's the single biggest security upgrade you can make.
Disclosure: Some links in this guide are affiliate links. We only recommend products we've tested and trust. Using these links doesn't cost you extra and helps keep AskBuy independent.
This page was written by the engine and the engine is still on the line. The conversation below picks up where the article stops.
Yes — the picks above are the engine's current verdicts. Ask a sharper version of this question below and you'll get a custom answer with the latest pricing.