Etsy Payments handles on-platform sales, but artisans selling at craft fairs, pop-ups, and independent websites need a separate payment processor. We compare Square, PayPal, Stripe, and Clover for the omnichannel artisan — covering in-person card readers, online checkout, inventory sync, and fees.
If you sell on Etsy, you already use Etsy Payments — it's been mandatory for all eligible sellers since 2017, centralizing payment acceptance, processing, and fund transfers for on-platform transactions.3 But that system only works inside Etsy. The moment you pack up your ceramics, prints, or candles for a craft fair, a weekend pop-up, or your own standalone website, you need a separate payment processor.
This guide covers the four best options for artisans who need to take payments anywhere — at a booth, on a custom site, or across borders — and keep their inventory and sales records in sync.
Square is the default choice for craft show vendors for good reason. Setup is free, there are no monthly fees, and the hardware (the Square Reader, which plugs into a phone or tablet) is the most intuitive on the market.2 You can be swiping cards at your booth within minutes of opening the box.
What makes Square especially useful for Etsy sellers is its inventory and reporting tools. Sales from your craft fair booth sync automatically to your main sales records, so you're not double-counting or manually reconciling at the end of the day.1 The per-transaction fee is 2.6% + 10¢ for swiped/dipped/tapped cards — competitive and transparent.
Best for: Artisans who sell primarily at in-person events and want the lowest friction setup.
PayPal is the payment method most international Etsy buyers already trust. For Etsy sellers, having PayPal as a familiar option for off-platform sales — whether through invoices, a simple "PayPal.me" link, or a buy button on a social post — makes it a natural extension of your existing workflow.3
PayPal also offers PayPal Zettle, a card reader for in-person sales that charges slightly lower per-transaction fees than Square for seasonal vendors.2 The PayPal app handles both online and offline payments in one dashboard, which simplifies things if you're already using PayPal for Etsy payouts.
Best for: Sellers who need a globally recognized payment method and want a single account for both online and in-person transactions.
If you're building your own website — whether through Shopify, WooCommerce, or a custom storefront — Stripe is the gold standard. Its API is powerful enough to handle complex subscription models, multi-currency checkouts, and custom payment flows, yet its prebuilt checkout pages work fine for a simple store.1
Stripe doesn't offer its own card-present hardware, so it's not a fit for craft fairs on its own. But paired with a third-party POS system or a platform like Squarespace, it's the best choice for artisans who want full control over their online storefront and are ready to scale beyond Etsy.
Best for: Artisans launching independent websites who need developer-friendly payment infrastructure.
Clover is overkill for most casual craft vendors, but if you're doing regular weekend markets, have a permanent retail booth, or are managing significant inventory, its hardware lineup (the Clover Flex, Mini, and Station) offers professional-grade POS capabilities. You get built-in inventory management, employee tracking, and detailed sales reporting — features Square's basic free tier doesn't match.
The trade-off is cost: Clover typically requires a monthly plan and longer-term contracts. It's a serious investment, but for high-volume artisans who treat their craft business as a full-time retail operation, the operational efficiency can justify the expense.
Best for: Full-time artisans and makers running high-transaction-volume booths or permanent retail spaces.
| Feature | Square | PayPal | Stripe | Clover |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Setup time | Minutes | Minutes | Hours–days | Days–weeks |
| In-person hardware | Square Reader | Zettle reader | Third-party only | Clover Flex/Mini/Station |
| Online checkout | Basic e-commerce | PayPal buttons / invoices | Full API / prebuilt | Via Clover online store |
| Monthly fees | None | None | None | $15–$60+ |
| Per-transaction fee | 2.6% + 10¢ (in-person) | 2.29% + 9¢ (in-person) | 2.9% + 30¢ (online) | Varies by plan |
For most Etsy sellers who do occasional craft fairs, Square is the right starting point — it's free, fast, and the inventory sync is a genuine time-saver.2 If you already rely on PayPal for your Etsy payouts and want a single login for everything, PayPal Zettle is a strong alternative with slightly lower swipe fees.
If you're building your own website and plan to grow beyond Etsy, Stripe gives you the most flexibility. And if your craft business has grown into a full-time retail operation with high transaction volumes, Clover is worth the monthly investment for the hardware and reporting power.
Disclosure: Some links in this article are affiliate links. If you sign up through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we've researched and believe are genuinely useful for artisans.
This page was written by the engine and the engine is still on the line. The conversation below picks up where the article stops.
Yes — the picks above are the engine's current verdicts. Ask a sharper version of this question below and you'll get a custom answer with the latest pricing.